Acoustic Sounds UHQR
Lyra
akhnaten LA Opera
By: Mark Ward

March 15th, 2026

Category:

Concerts

Philip Glass’s "Akhnaten" at LA Opera: A Stunning Re-Invention of Opera

Yes, it is possible for opera to be “relevant”, Mr. Chalamet… Includes a brief discography of recommended Philip Glass recordings.

I just had one of the most thrilling, unique and compelling experiences in a lifetime of going to the theater and opera: Philip Glass’s Akhnaten, at the Los Angeles Opera.

John Holiday as Akhnaten (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)John Holiday as Akhnaten (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Actually it was mind-blowing.  Visually arresting, theatrically innovative, musically gorgeous and exhilarating.  A completely new kind of performance experience which reinvented opera, music, theater - indeed the intersections of all the arts - in the same way that Wagner’s Der Ring des Nibelungen did 150 years ago.  It also posed and answered the fundamental question that composers have been grappling with since the “disintegration” of tonality just over a century ago: how to move forward without being derivative, yet also without alienating your audience.

How to create art in the 21st century that is truly original but also accessible.  And fun!

And yes, it had jugglers!!!  Ten of them, onstage throughout!  That’s its own particular pleasure…

My reviews on this site over the last months have been much preoccupied with many of these same concerns - whither classical music after the upheavals of the late 19th and early 20th centuries - as I was reviewing  Karajan’s Second Viennese School box, and the Liszt Via Crucis.  (Going back further I wrote extensively about these issues in my review of Solti’s recording of Wagner’s Ring cycle in its new digital and vinyl incarnations).

Since I am about to review the Original Source reissue of Das Rheingold from Karajan’s recorded Ring cycle, as well as several reissues from DG’s important series of mid-20th century Avant Garde releases, plus the Decca Pure Analogue reissue of Zubin Mehta’s seminal record of Edgar Varèse, all of this contemplation of what classical music was, where it was going in the 20th century, and will be as the 21st century unfolds, is front and center in my brain.  The result?

Akhnaten went off like the proverbial firecracker.

And I simply had to write about it.

DVD/CD of Akhnaten from Metropolitan Opers

Since this exact same production (with different singers) is available on DVD and CD, you can get some sense of what I am going to be talking about by getting hold of one or both of those.  At the end of this article I will also post the currently available YouTube videos of the live Met broadcast.

I will also be providing you with a short selection of my favorite Philip Glass recordings at the end.

Akhnaten Act 2 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Akhnaten Act 2 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

WHAT IS AKHNATEN?

Not what you expect from a 3-hour opera, that’s for sure.

It’s the third of Philip Glass’s trilogy of biographical operas in which he used the lives of three seminal figures to explore ideas surrounding science (Einstein on the Beach 1976), politics (Mahatma Gandhi in Satyagraha 1980), and religion (Akhnaten 1984).

Akhnaten focuses on the elusive Pharaoh Amenhotep IV, later renamed as Akhenaten (ruling from c. 1351 - 1334 B.C.), who rejected his country’s centuries-old worship of many gods to impose one of the earliest examples of monotheism on his culture, in this case the worship of the Sun.  He built an entire city to glorify this new religion, Akhetaten (aka Amarna).

Sculpture of Ahkenaten in the Alexandria National MuseumSculpture of Ahkenaten in the Alexandria National Museum

After his death, the old powers and religion reasserted themselves, and effectively scrubbed Akhenaten from the history books.

Akhenaten and Nefertiti worshipping the Sun God, AtenAkhenaten and Nefertiti worshipping the Sun God, Aten

For Glass, this conflict between the old and the new within the religious sphere was the perfect sequel to his similar explorations of the same themes in science and politics in his earlier operas.

Philip GlassPhilip Glass

Philip Glass was one of group of composers including Terry Riley and Steve Reich who went in the opposite direction of their modernist contemporaries like Karlheinz Stockhausen and Pierre Boulez in Europe, Milton Babbitt and Elliot Carter in America, rejecting the complexities of atonality and serialism to re-embrace the core principles that had driven Western Music for centuries: a return to the diatonic harmonic system (but also using the modal model) and the primacy of rhythm.  Integrated into this model was a strong influence from other musical cultures, like the Indian raga and African drumming.

So when you listen to Philip Glass’s music you will primarily hear diatonic chords outlined in arpeggios in differing time signatures, with opposing dissonances and chords gaining weight and power because of their non-conformity to the dominant patterns.  The effect is to focus the ear like a laser beam on every slight shift in the musical design, every deviation from the primary chords, and to induce an almost trance-like state. 

“What you hear depends on how you focus your ear. We’re not talking about inventing a new language, but rather inventing new perceptions of existing languages.”

 – Philip Glass

And that includes the “language” of opera.

Considering that opera was long seen as the epitome of the “old” ways of classical music, remaining viable (but still set in 19th century form and tradition) into the 20th century in the works of Benjamin Britten, Leonard Bernstein, Shostakovich and others, it was inevitable that when Glass turned to the form he had to come up with a different approach to the dramatic mise en scéne that would be a better match for his more stylized musical language - the complete opposite of the Wagnerian music-drama model.

What he came up with is epitomized by Akhnaten in its structure, its music, its use of voices, its scenario, its reinvention of traditional dramatic scenes.  All of these qualities are further enhanced by this particular production directed by Phelim McDermott, originally an LAOpera co-production with English National Opera, the Metropolitan Opera, and Gran Teatre del Liceu.

Philip Glass and Phelim McDermottPhilip Glass and Phelim McDermott

An important note on the unusual sound of the score itself.  A particular sonic distinction of  Akhnaten is the absence of violins - the orchestra is led instead by the viola section.  For the premiere in Stuttgart there wasn’t enough room for a full string section in the orchestra pit of the smaller Kleines Haus then in use while the main auditorium was under renovation.  Therefore Glass decided to dispense with the violins altogether.  The resulting darker hue to the score is perfect for the evocation of Ancient Egypt.

Akhnaten Act 1: The Robing of the New Pharaoh (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver).Akhnaten Act 1: The Robing of the New Pharaoh (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver).

OPERA AS CEREMONY AND RITUAL

Forget about the kind of conventional plotting, character development  and action you are used to seeing in the theater or on the opera stage.

And forget about conventional musical forms like arias, ensembles and choruses.  Everything is repurposed to the new design.

Glass’s music in the eight minute-or-so prelude sets the scene for what is to follow.  Arpeggiated diatonic figures in the violas then migrating to other instruments combine with chanting chords, simple solo lines that often introduce deeply felt dissonances - all of these elements communicate something familiar yet also foreign, and a sense of entering another world settles upon the audience.

Interestingly this is very similar to how Wagner opens his similarly revolutionary Ring cycle (from 150 years ago) at the beginning of Das Rheingold.  Again the purpose is to draw the audience into hearing and feeling differently, to draw them into a new type of theatrical experience.  In the prelude of Das Rheingold, low unison bass notes slowly expand to encompass the basic diatonic scale, as if we are witnessing the birth of the world (we are) - as the deep waters of the Rhine reveal themselves on stage.  The musical language is strikingly similar to Philip Glass’s, although Wagner’s music drama will soon expand into a full-blown late-Romantic idiom, replete with chromaticism and the kind of harmonic fluidity which is the opposite of Glass’s more ostensibly conservative harmonic approach.  With Glass you know exactly where you are harmonically, because you are hearing that same key outlined in a chord over and over again.  Until everything shifts under your feet, like vast tectonic plates moving across centuries.

Instead of presenting a traditional dramatic scenario, each Act of the opera is a series of tableaus designed to present key moments, both historical and thematic, from Akhnaten’s life.

The Extraction of the dead Pharoaoh Amenhotep's Heart, ready to be weighed against a feather to determine whether he will enter the After-Life (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver).The Extraction of the dead Pharoaoh Amenhotep's Heart, ready to be weighed against a feather to determine whether he will enter the After-Life (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver).

Act One encompasses the death of his father Amenhoetep III, the ritual of his passage to the afterlife, the presentation and crowning of Akhnaten, and the new Pharoah’s pronouncement that from now on all will worship one god only, the sun god Aten.

John Holiday as Akhnaten (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Akhnaten (John Holiday) pronouncing Aten as the new One God (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Act Two depicts the ten years of Akhnaten’s reign in which he builds his city and confirms the new monotheistic religion.  It includes a ravishing reinvention of the operatic love duet in a spellbinding scene between the Pharoah and his Queen, Nefertiti.  It ends with Akhnaten’s Hymn to the Sun, the core of the opera, from which everything else radiates outwards.

John Holiday as Akhnaten in Act 2 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)John Holiday as Akhnaten in Act 2 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Act Three depicts the downfall of Akhnaten and the re-establishment of the old ways, and the coronation of the child Pharaoh Tutankhamun.  It concludes in the present day, with tourists visiting the ancient sites, unable to grasp the full import of what went before.  But in a brilliant coup de théâtre, the ghosts of Akhnaten, Nefertiti and Akhnaten's mother Queen Tye reappear, and one is left with a sense of the Ancient World still being present, seeping into our modern world from across the centuries.

Act 1 of Akhnaten  (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Act 1 of Akhnaten, with So Young Park as Queen Tye (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

The stage set - brilliantly conceived by Tom Pye - is presented on three levels, two dimensional, designed to look like hieroglyphics. 

Act 1 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Act 1 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Echoing the sense of conventional notions of time being suspended in Glass’s music, in this production all physical movement is slowed down, with actors moving very slowly across the stage.  The effect is to form an endlessly changing series of “stage pictures”, constantly evolving in slow motion.  Since the action is spread across three levels and across different areas of the stage itself, every time you move your eyes to one area, then move to another, then move back again, everything is evolving.  It is an exact visual manifestation of how the music is working.

Akhnaten Act 2: The Narrator (Amenhotep, played by Zachary James) with jugglers (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Akhnaten Act 2: The Narrator (Amenhotep III, played by Zachary James) with jugglers (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

In the Second Act this set is gradually split asunder, opening up to a wide open stage over which is suspended the vast orb of the sun.  In front of this Akhnaten sings his Hymn to Aten, to words we know were written by the Pharaoh himself.  The Act concludes with a stunning stage picture of the Pharaoh ascending steps to almost embrace the Sun as it beams down upon him and his kingdom - implacable, unknowable, awe-inspiring - as any god should be.

Akhnaten (John Holiday) with the Sun (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Akhnaten (John Holiday) with the Sun (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

In the Third Act the set returns once more to its original “hieroglyphic” setting, the multiple levels playing host to different areas of the action.

Enhancing the sense of deep connection to both the environment and  culture of Ancient Egypt are the extraordinary costumes of Kevin Pollard, which combine what you’d expect from the world of the Pharaohs with elements of Elizabethan and Victorian, even punk, stylings. Fans of the great Jean Paul Gaultier (no stranger himself to film costume design) will recognize echoes of that designer's distinctive "look" - though this is in no way meant to detract from Pollard's singular accomplishments here.

(from l. to r.) Aye (Vinicius Costa), High Priest of Amon (Yuntong Han) and General Horemhab (Hyungjin Son)  (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)(from l. to r.) Aye (Vinicius Costa), High Priest of Amon (Yuntong Han) and General Horemhab (Hyungjin Son) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

The only physical movement onstage that is not “slowed-down” is necessarily the arm movements of the jugglers, and the balls they are juggling - since these are subject to the regular laws of physics.  Even here, though, the balls move in different tempi according to how they are juggled and manipulated.

The Gandini Juggling Troupe in Akhnaten (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)The Gandini Juggling Troupe in Akhnaten (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Throughout the production the jugglers, members of the ground-breaking Gandini Juggling group, are used to provide a visual correlative to the music’s ebbs and flows, and to also express the physical intent of the dramatic conflicts being otherwise ritualized onstage. 

The High Priest of Amon (Yontong Han) in Act 2 of Akhnaten (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)The High Priest of Amon (Yontong Han) in Act 2 of Akhnaten. In this scene the jugglers represent the forces unleashed by Akhnaten to tear down the old pantheistic religious order, and their juggling suggests both physical and ideological threat. Note how the white balls have been replaced by the more aggressive juggling clubs, which are thrown and brandished like weapons throughout this scene. (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

For example, in the Act 3 attack on the Pharoah and family, the jugglers - lying prone on the stage - move like slow-motion tidal waves of an oncoming storm, enveloping Ahknaten (along with the malevolent chorus) with their juggling. As the Pharaoh gasps his last breath, falling into the arms of his father Amenhotep, the balls fall to the ground motionless, strewn across the stage, and the jugglers disappear completely.

It is only in the final minutes of the opera, as the ghosts of Ahknaten and his Queen, along with Queen Tye, sing once again, that balls slowly begin to roll - at first almost imperceptibly - across the stage. They are followed by the return of the jugglers, likewise moving slowly across the stage between the three standing principals - on all-fours.  A ripple through time? Using the simplest of means, a sense of continuity is re-established.  The past speaks to the present. It’s yet another spellbinding coup de théâtre in an evening full of them.

The idea to use jugglers came to director Phelim McDermott while he was doing a session in an isolation tank. Contacting the legendary Sean Gandini (whom I used to see performing in Covent Garden when I lived in London in the 1980s, and whose troupe perform in this production), he was delighted to discover that the earliest representation of juggling is to be found in Ancient Egyptian art. It seemed like creative destiny. Throughout the opera the jugglers present a visual correlative to the ebb and flow of the music. Their use is a stunning creative coup.

Let’s take a moment here to talk about how Glass uses his singers.  There are few conventional “scenes” between characters, beyond the big love duet between Akhnaten and his bride.  This is a scene of uncommon intensity, where the two lovers approach slowly from opposite ends of the stage, wrapped in bright red “togas” with long trains stretching back to the wings. 

Akhnaten (John Holiday) and Nefertiti (Sun-Ly Pierce)  (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Akhnaten (John Holiday) and Nefertiti (Sun-Ly Pierce) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

As the duet climaxes they wrap around each other, as do these trains, and then part.  Rarely have separate and intertwining pieces of cloth moving slowly across the stage held such import.

Akhnaten (John Holiday) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Akhnaten (John Holiday) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Scenes are tableaux, depictions of characters’ position or ideology rather than conventional dramatic, psychological interactions.  All the texts are in their original “dead” languages.  Some scenes are sung merely to wordless “aahs”.  It is the intent - sometimes loving, sometimes fearful, sometimes violent - behind the vocalizations which Glass expresses in his settings of them, and the music accompanying them.

The big exception here is the role of the dead Amenhotep III, father of Akhnaten, who steps forward to become the opera’s narrator during the opening scene, present onstage most of the time, speaking directly to the audience in English. 

Amenhotep III (Zachary James) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Amenhotep III (Zachary James) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

This is a device that has been used often before, rarely successfully; here it provides a compelling bridge between the audience and what is unfolding onstage: a very human character expressing all the emotional reaction to what is happening in the strange, unfolding drama we are all witnessing.

Amenhotep III (Zachary James) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Amenhotep III (Zachary James) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Finally one must mention Glass’s decision to write the role of Akhnaten for a counter-tenor.  It is a full 40 minutes into the opera before we hear the Pharaoh sing, even though his presence has already been mightily felt as he is literally “born” onstage (an entirely justifiable - and striking - use of full nudity that is necessarily diluted in the broadcast version linked to below).  When those slightly other-worldly tones of the counter-tenor voice emerge the sense of this distant civilization’s simultaneously alien quality and also strange familiarity is immediately underlined.  

When the opera premiered back in 1984, the role was taken by one of the leading (and pioneering) counter-tenors back then, Paul Esswood (brother of my ‘cello teacher).  The slight hootiness of the voice was typical of the time, and frankly I find it hard to listen to now (on the original cast recording, available on vinyl and CD on CBS/Sony), especially when the current generation of vocal and opera stars contains a multitude of brilliant counter-tenors who are anything but hard to listen to.  Much better - for this reason alone - to go with the Met Opera recording on CD and DVD. 

Only one section of the opera is sung in the vernacular of the audience, in this case English, and that is Akhnaten’s Hymn to the Sun, expressed in his own verified historical words. 

Thou dost appear beautiful
On the horizon of heaven
Oh, living Aten
He who was the first to live

When thou hast risen on the Eastern Horizon
Thou art fair, great, dazzling,
High above every land
Thy rays encompass the land
To the very end of all thou hast made.

All the beasts are satisfied with their pasture
Trees and plants are verdant
Birds fly from their nests, wings spread
Flocks skip with their feet
All that fly and alight
Live when thou hast arisen.
How manifold is that which thou hast made
Thou sole God
There is no other like thee
Thou didst create the earth
According to thy will
Being alone, everything on earth
Which walks and flies on high.
Thy rays nourish the fields
When thou dost rise
They live and thrive for thee
Thou makest the seasons to nourish
All thou hast made
The winter to cool
The heat that they may taste thee.
There is no other that knows thee
Save thy son, Akhnaten
For thou hast made him skilled
In thy plans and thy might
Thou dost raise him up for thy son
Who comes forth from thyself.

Hymn to the Sun (John Holiday)  (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Hymn to the Sun (John Holiday) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

BRINGING THE MYSTERY OF ANCIENT EGYPT TO LIFE

“I feel like in the first Act we release the ancient Egyptian gods, the spirits from their tombs, and they have a chance through this extraordinary medium to communicate some of what that culture is like, which I don’t think you can get from just getting the facts, as of course there’s beautiful music that’s communicating that as well.”

— Phelim McDermott, director of Akhnaten

Forget every other depiction of Ancient Egypt you’ve ever seen or read about.  This music and this production bring the Land of the Pharoahs to tangible life in a manner I’ve never experienced before.  Forget all those megabucks historical epics stretching back to Cecil B. DeMille spectacles like The Ten Commandments (1923 and 1956) which spent millions on recreating every last historical and imagined detail of the period.  Forget Ridley Scott’s typically immersive art-directed film about the conflict between Moses and Ramses, Exodus: Gods and Kings (2014), to date the most authentic representation of life under the Pharaohs.  Forget the Tutankhamun exhibition which I attended in London as a wide-eyed 12-year-old.

Tutankhamun actually makes an appearance in Act 3 of Akhnaten, crowned onstage and in real life at the age of 9, since he was the successor to the deposed and murdered Akhnaten (though not necessarily his biological son).

The Crowning of Tutankhamun (Schroeder Shelby-Szyszko) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)The Crowning of Tutankhamun (Schroeder Shelby-Szyszko) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

No, Akhnaten brings the mystery, glory and excess of Ancient Egypt to life like nothing else I’ve ever experienced.  Also, especially in this stellar production, it captures unerringly the allure of religious fervour, and the faint odour of corruption one associates with dynasties and that same religious zeal as it becomes institutionalized and ossified.  During one of the intervals I chatted to a middle-aged couple who were attending with a group of friends.  They had all gone on a recent excursion to Egypt that had encompassed as many of the tombs, sights and museums as most of us could bear - in short the whole historical tourist experience with a vengeance.  Their eyes lit up when I asked them if they were enjoying the show.  “Oh yes, it’s incredible - just like being there - in the ancient times,” they replied, “and we don’t like opera - we only ever went once before, years ago, and it was not our thing at all.  This is different.”

Yes, this show might be the perfect introduction to “opera” for a newbie, precisely because it is so unlike what most people think opera is - or how they have experienced it.

The Daughters of Akhnaten under attack (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)The Daughters of Akhnaten under attack (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

MAKING OPERA RELEVANT AGAIN?

Hell yeah!

In case you’ve been hiding under a rock recently, the “relevance” of opera and ballet has been much in the news owing to an offhand series of remarks Timothée Chalemet made during a town hall with Matthew McConaughey to promote his Oscar chances.

All the old arguments about the “elitism” of opera and ballet, and the funding of same, have reared their hoary heads.

I’m always entertained when a celebrity allows their ego to get the better of their ignorance - so that they let fly with a pronouncement that puts both fully on display.  But poor Timothée - you really do not want to get on the wrong side of Whoopi and the Ladies of “The View”…

I cannot think of a better riposte to Chalemet’s dismissal of opera than this production of Akhnaten. Rarely have I experienced an artistic “happening” (for that is most surely what it was) that was so completely immersive, so completely original and different to anything else you might experience in a theater; that spoke in such a compelling way to my core being.  And that resonated (and continues to resonate - or should I say pulsate) within my consciousness.

I was not alone.  The audience was totally into it, and the reviews across the board - from critics (the ones that are left) and audience members online - have been ecstatic.

Not bad for a so-called “dead”, “irrelevant” art form.

Make no mistake - this is opera like you’ve never seen or imagined it, and, I’ll wager, unlikely to see again - until the next Phelim McDermott production of a Philip Glass opera.

No, from the dramatic scenario, to the score, to the production in every aspect - sets, costumes, lighting, movement - this was a complete re-invention of the theatrical experience.  This was not like any other music drama I’ve ever seen - and I’ve seen some pretty way out there stuff!

Actually Akhnaten is exactly what “opera” is (or should be, at its best): a blending of music, words, singing drama and theater to create a mode of artistic expression more intense than anything its constituent parts could create on their own.  It’s just that we’ve gotten so used to the operatic mainstays of the past that they are locked within the aesthetic context of the times in which they were created.

Akhnaten breaks all the shackles of the past and present.  This isn’t necessarily a given for a “new” opera.  The self-professed avant-garde is often as dull and reactionary as the orthodoxy it professes to replace.  I regret to say I actually attended Stockhausen’s Donnerstag aus Licht at Covent Garden, part of that composer’s seven (count them - seven) opera cycle intended as his one-upping of Wagner’s merely four part Ring cycle. A bigger pile of pretentious, inauthentic doo-dah I cannot recall: an assemblage of every masturbatory “modernist” pseudo-intellectual gesture and cliché known to man.  And also, by the way, horrible to listen to - an opera composed and performed by inmates of an asylum would at least have the benefit of unpredictability.

And yet here we are with Philip Glass’s Akhnaten, something truly avant-garde, yet built resolutely upon the mighty edifice of traditional tonality, all chords and arpeggios we know from our earliest days of hammering out “3 Blind Mice” at the piano. Notes that are not part of the chords begin to appear, and build their own chord and figures.  Different instruments and sections of the orchestra either take up the main musical material, or offer their own version of it.  Because the textures are so transparent, because often we are dealing with opposing outlines of chords, rather than all the notes in-between that we are used to hearing in conventional classical music, there can be thrilling juxtapositions of the simplest material.  

From an audiophile point of view, Glass’s use of deep unison bass notes against filigree writing in the mid-range and upper staves creates incredible moments of bass “presence” that really make you understand the prioritizing of bass performance in a stereo system.

The music is foundational, standing before you like some mighty rock face - El Capitan maybe - but then as you look closely you see the cracks and contours of the granite, shifting patterns in the stone as the sun catches it in changing light through the day; and then when it rains, the rivulets of moisture flowing down in altering channels are the ripples in the musical textures that Glass builds, turns on their axes, and which re-emerge both the same and altered.

El Capitan photographed by Ansel AdamsEl Capitan photographed by Ansel Adams

If you could stand and look closely at the face of El Capitan over the course of a day, see how it alters yet stays the same - that’s how Glass’s unique way with the Western musical vernacular impedes on your ear, your brain, your mind and finally your deeper consciousness. I am still “feeling” this music in my body and mind days on from the performance. This is quite different to how regular music works.  And to be honest I have often resisted it.  I have often shied away from Glass’s music, instead favoring that of Steve Reich and John Adams in particular.  

But here, in this opera, there is somehow a perfect match of music and subject, and I was powerless before it - and happy to be so.  If the mighty pyramids and tombs and Pharaohs of Ancient Egypt could speak - this would be their language.

Akhnaten Act 2 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Akhnaten Act 2 (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

Dalia Stasevska conducting the LA Opera Orchestra (superbly)  (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)Dalia Stasevska conducting the LA Opera Orchestra (superbly) (LA Opera; photo by Cory Weaver)

AKHNATEN ON VIDEO and CD

Videos of Akhnaten, like all filmed-in-the-theatre opera and plays, tend to be an unsatisfactory substitute for the real thing.  But it’s better than nothing.  If you ever have a chance to see this production in the flesh, grab it. (It is playing in LA until the 22nd March).  Otherwise, below is the live transmission of a performance from the Met - same production, different singers.  (In the performance I saw at LAOpera, the young counter-tenor John Holiday was even more otherworldly and spellbinding than Anthony Roth Costanzo in the Akhnaten role, which is saying something.  A singer to seriously watch out for).  

Goodness only knows how long these links will stay active on YouTube.  The great opera star Joyce DiDonato is a most ingratiating host, and there are some really nice behind-the-scenes interviews and peeks at the company getting ready to perform.

I will also mention a nice close-up look at one of Tom Pye’s most striking costumes. 

If you want a more permanent version of Akhnaten then seek out either the CD or DVD versions from the Met on Philip Glass’s own label - same production, different singers from those currently performing at  LAOpera.  This is not available on streaming services.

There is also the original recording on CBS/Sony vinyl and CD, conducted by Dennis Russell Davies.  There is also a more recent Music on Vinyl pressing of this.  I haven’t found this on streaming services either, although it is on YouTube.  I would go for the Met Opera version, but Glass fans will want to have both.

Philip Glass Akhnaten CBS cover

FURTHER LISTENING - PHILIP GLASS RECOMMENDATIONS

As to other recommended Philip Glass recordings, I will begin with two personal essentials.

Philip Glass Aguas da Amazonia

“Águas da Amazônia, Sete ou oito peças para um balé” (Portuguese for 'Waters of the Amazon, seven or eight pieces for a ballet’).  This is the one Philip Glass work I keep in active rotation (in its CD incarnation - you can also stream it).  A musical depiction of the rivers of the Amazon, it was a collaboration with the ensemble Uakti, and is notable for its intricate use of percussion and unusual wind textures.  I adore this piece, and while there are several newer recordings of this you might want to explore, start with the original.  Beautiful sound too.

Philip Glass Piano Works Vikingur Olafsson

This recording of a selection of Philip Glass’s astonishing piano works was the calling card of the young Icelandic pianist, Víkingur Ólafsson.  It, and his follow-up Bach recital, turned him into a superstar.  No other recording of these works comes close, and getting this set (available on vinyl and CD) prompted me on my recent journey to re-appraise Glass’s music.

Philip on Film - Filmworks by Philip Glass

Film music has long been at the core of Philip Glass’s musical identity and passion - and this excellent box set (which you will have to find on the used market) is a superb overview of his earlier work in this area.  Of course you have excerpts from the groundbreaking Koyaanisqatsi (1982) and Powaqqatsi (1988), his collaborations with director Godfrey Reggio, and the place where most of my generation first became aware of Glass’s music, but you also have some nice chunks from his scores to Dracula and La Belle et la Bête, plus further extracts from Mishima, The Thin Blue Line and Kundun, amongst others.  From there you can go on to explore the complete soundtracks to these films.

Philip Glass The Illusionist Soundtrack

This is one of Glass’s finest soundtracks in my opinion, and what an unusual choice made by director Neil Burger for this highly evocative period drama that is sometimes unfairly overlooked in favor of the almost exactly contemporaneous The Prestige (2006), directed by Christopher Nolan. Glass’s score is mesmerizing and romantic, the perfect musical corollary to the strange tale of love and magic the film tells.  This is also available as a Music on Vinyl release.

Comments

  • 2026-03-15 08:22:39 PM

    Come on wrote:

    Reminds me on my John Adams „Nixon in China“ live opera experience, which was fantastic, although, seemingly as the Glass Opera, it certainly didn’t have the joy of live and positive vibe of an old Italian opera, nor passion and drama of a Wagner opera. Those modern operas in my perception somehow exude a cold, misanthropic musical atmosphere, which can still be quite an experience. Like an apocalyptic movie.

    • 2026-03-16 01:31:20 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      I know what you mean... and btw I saw the first production of Nixon in China at the Kennedy Centre and loved it, but it is a far more conventional piece than Akhnaten. I don't find Akhnaten cold in the least - which is surprising given its musical and dramatic profile.

  • 2026-03-15 08:33:04 PM

    Stephen CP Carroll wrote:

    Mark - I’m always excited to see a new article (“review” just doesn’t do them justice) from you on here. And I wholeheartedly agree with this one. I have say that I was a bit sceptical the first time I saw Akhnaten at The Met, especially after a big holiday dinner. I was worried I was going to be “That Guy” snoring in the grand Tier sometime between hours two and three. And HOW wrong I was. Anthony Roth Costanza was astonishing, and the entire production , cast, score, orchestra, and experience were gripping - as you say, nothing less than thrilling. The hours flew by, and like when I get off any self-respecting roller coaster (or relationship, for that matter, but that’s a whole different website), walking out onto the Lincoln Center piazza I was literally bouncing up and down repeating “ I wanna do it again!” So I did. Twice more that season. Thank you for all the suggestions about what Philip Glass I’m going to listen to now that you have me remembering that production. I’m going to be deep into those before I know it. Can’t wait to see what you write about next.

    • 2026-03-16 01:32:44 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      Thank you for your kind words of support - what a great story. We are debating whether to try and see it again before it leaves!

  • 2026-03-16 10:55:24 AM

    Thomas Ream wrote:

    Mark, absolutely brilliantly done. IMHO, one of the key, if in fact not the most important element of crtiticism, is to educate, something you have done here in spades. Back in the day when the minimalists were getting started I was the classical music critic for my university news paper, and I cannot tell you how much 20th garbage I had to listen to, from the kinds of composers you cite, and I have always maintained that melody was a key component of music, especiallly opera. One might be able to argue that Glass overweighted on the concept of tunefulness...but the music is accessible in a way that a work by Babbit or Stockhausen will never be - not that they cared or had that as an objective. I did purchase Glassworks when it was first released, and wondered if Mr. Glass was having us on, but the record of the operas and the film music speak for themselves. One more comment - we have a combination of no new operas entering the basic repertoire (inaccessibley composed) as well as the tyrannical revisionism of Regietheater, which does make Chalamet's comment more relevant. I have seen Lohengrin staged twice - once where the director decided to set it during the Hungarian revolution, because that was "interesting", and the second (the recent Viennese production brilliantly led by Thielemann) where the plot was changed to show that Elsa did murder her brother after all, in direct contradiction to the composers intentions. I don't mind of bit of rethinking if it provides a truly new view of a work, but to change it so dramatically is wrongheaded. To summarize, we need new tunes we can whistle, something Mozart understand but most modern composers don't.....I will go with Mozart every time!

    • 2026-03-16 01:37:46 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      Thank you for so much for the positive feedback. And a big shout out to MF for letting me write about this little corner of our musical passions. Don't even get me started on modern wayward opera productions. I get really ticked off when these directors actually change the text - it's like giving a happy ending to Hamlet! You'll get no argument from me on Mozart...!

      • 2026-03-18 05:27:44 PM

        Silk Dome Mid wrote:

        Hamlet does have a happy ending! Denmark and the world in general were clearly better off without all those flakes, murderers and mentally unbalanced people running the kingdom.

  • 2026-03-16 03:10:23 PM

    Michael Stöber wrote:

    Now I am curious Mark! I will watch the videos and am looking for the mentioned CDs from the met.

    • 2026-03-17 03:42:33 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      Splendid!

  • 2026-03-17 02:43:56 AM

    Jennnifer Martin wrote:

    I'm so happy that you got to see/hear it! (Maybe my old friends Steve Piazza is still on bass clarinet, Bill Booth and Terry Cravens on trombone? Sadly my dear friend Jim Self (tuba) recently passed away.)

    • 2026-03-17 03:41:59 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      The bass wind and brass parts were sounding particularly resplendent the night I went!

  • 2026-03-17 02:20:47 PM

    Andrew Kemp wrote:

    Dear Mark. Great article as ever. I well remember that 1984 ENO production. It's hard to credit now how radical and even "difficult" Glass was considered to be back then. The "stuck in a groove" jibe seemed to be well and truly stuck in it's own groove! Fortunately I was already primed in minimalism having bought the DG Steve Reich box when it first came out (one's Blackwells account was good for more than the latest critical edition of Beowulf!) and by that stage I was working for Reich's publisher, soon also to be John Adams's. Thinking of Reich and Glass, I have always considered them to be, in an odd way, the modern day Chopin and Liszt, i.e. Chopin writes 100 works and produces 95 masterpieces; Liszt writes 1000 works and produces, yes, 95 masterpieces. So, as with Liszt, I find that with Glass you definitely have to pick and choose. I certainly wouldn't quarrel with any of your choices and like you love The Illusionist both as a film and for Glass's wonderful score. In many ways it's Glass's soundtracks that give the lie to any suggestion that Glass's music is fundamentally all the same, as it manages to underpin and enhance a very wide range of emotions and dramatic situations in a variety of films that could not be more different from each other. However, going beyond your selection I would perhaps just add that his string quartets are also well worth a listen. Thanks again for most stimulating read.

    • 2026-03-17 03:49:56 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      Ah, the days of having a Blackwells account!!! I definitely indulged... Was Raymond Glaspole still managing the music store in your day? We played together in a little ad hoc broken consort (he on bass gamba, me on recorders and gamba). So much fun working our way through all that gorgeous English music on summer evenings, our consort strains floating across the Sussex fields - Purcell, Dowland, Jenkins... You make some excellent observations, and that is a great point re. Reich and Glass. I considered putting in the string quartets, but am not overly familiar with them, or a particular version, so decided to stick with the recordings I know really well. A lot of people do not know about that Amazon Rivers disc - if you don't, I urge you to give it a spin.

      • 2026-03-18 07:29:42 AM

        Andrew Kemp wrote:

        Yes, Raymond Glaspole was the manager back in my time at Oxford. I can still remember his world weary sigh as I returned my set of the Karajan 'Tristan' for the second or third time. He then sadly informed me that not only had all their original stock been returned faulty but now with my return all their replacement stock as well, and that my only hope was to write direct to EMI about it. I took his advice and eventually received a set "personally checked by EMI engineers" - far from perfect but at least playable. EMI was going through a bad patch pressing wise at the time with loud passages preceded, punctuated or followed (sometimes all three) by loud crunching distortion - presumably a cutting error. On another occasion I was chatting to one of the assistants, who turned out to be Jan Morris's son and nephew of Gareth Morris who had been principal flautist in the Philharmonia and then New Philharmonia Orchestra. We ended up discussing the then newly issued Boulez 'Parsifal' and he kindly gave me his complimentary copy, which I still have, now snuggling up to Solti in my opera section. But perhaps my most memorable Blackwells encounter was passing Jessye Norman on the stairs down to the record department; she was, and I hope I won't be thought ungallant for saying so, a very wide lady! At that time, probably about 1973, she was by no means the megastar she later became, but I recognised her from my set of Colin Davis's 'Le Nozze di Figaro' which I had bought a year or so earlier. It must have been around the time she was appearing as Elisabeth in 'Tannhauser' at Covent Garden, the performance I saw being notable for one of the battens being accidentally dropped from the fly tower and almost braining Norman Bailey who was singing Wolfram. Happy days! (Comment written while listening to Amazon Rivers - good advice from you as ever.)

        • 2026-03-18 01:24:09 PM

          Mark Ward wrote:

          There are so many levels of "It's a small world" here. By Jan Morris I assume you mean the brilliant author and historian, formerly James? She and my father were good friends going back to being on Everest '53 together - James was embedded with the expedition as the Times correspondent (just google Michael Ward Everest). We stayed with the family when I was very young so I knew those kids way back when. There's much more to this story I could tell you, but not here... Ah Raymond! I believe he is still alive. Lovely fellow, and he sure knew his records, but I do now recall he could get a little bit hot under the collar when a tricky musical passage was eluding him on the viol. We actually met whilst both attending a summer school in Bath for period instruments/early music, where we had wonderful teachers - John Holloway, Colin Tilney, Peter Vel (my gamba teacher, also a 'cellist in the RPO), and the later notorious Philip Pickett (whom I believe to still be in prison). For some years Raymond advertised in the Gramophone as a used records dealer. I have that Karajan Tristan - but it's been years since I played it. My fave Tristan on record (and no pressing faults that I can remember - how eerily predictive of the whole OSS pressing frustrations). I've never owned the Boulez Parsifal - but love the Solti and the Karajan. I think it's in the fab Boulez Sony CD box - so now I am reminded to listen to it. Actually saw Parsifal with Reginald Goodall - VERY slow. - think it was ENO (also saw him do Tristan with Welsh National Opera in Oxford). I have that same Figaro and it is wonderful - my fave along with Bohm on DG and Solti on Decca (if only that one has an analogue back-up...) I guess you must have been at Oxford a little ahead of me - I was '79-82. Happy days. Feel free to email me personally to continue the chat - just email Michael at Tracking Angle and he will pass on your message.

  • 2026-03-18 12:20:29 PM

    Jack Pot wrote:

    Mesmerizing. Opera is Total Art! Perhaps one day, it will blow my way. Who agrees on the parallels: https://youtu.be/TfQJZ76WR0U?is=FyHpX9dIeUaezW_K

    • 2026-03-18 01:35:32 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      Jack, what a FABULOUS video!!! Will now see if the rest of this production is online. The music some will recognize from Marc Minkowski's epic record Rameau "Symphonie Imaginaire" - an essential "own" for anyone into Baroque music.

  • 2026-03-21 04:06:57 PM

    Steven Segal wrote:

    The English National Opera did this juggling production about 6 years ago. I really enjoyed it. I never understood the juggling. Not something to listen to on the stereo. They also did Satyagraha and Orpheus. Satyagraha Was my favourite.

  • 2026-03-26 05:22:23 AM

    SeagoatLeo wrote:

    My wife and I who saw this production several years ago at LA Opera thought it was an abysmal experience and at least 1/3 of the audience left after the first act. It wasn't as horrifying at the Lucia di Lammermoor with ghosts, gushing blood, attempted rape, blown heads off on wife screen, etc. which I renamed the Abortion of Lucia. I have seen over 400 opera performances live. I have over 10,000 LPs, CDs and 78s of classical vocal and opera recordings I have recorded orchestral, chamber and choral performances in major L.A. venues. Certainly there is a sound and appreciation of all sorts of music. I happen to think as an opera rather than just another luxurious choreographed and staged play with awful music, no arias and shear nonsensical storyline (six daughters die at the end, all they do is leave the stage, no singing plus those rolling balls). I saw the entirety waiting for a vocal climax, none, just more animated ball rolling. The opening "prelude" was typical Glass but just anxiety producing. What a POS opera which is my opinion. Other great new operas and rarely performed have occurred since then including Omar and Highway 1 USA which we and apparently the entire audience loved. That's my take in this tepid POS "opera." It was beautiful and bad, not disgusting as was the 1940's-2000 mismash and horrifying Lucia.

    • 2026-03-26 05:30:59 AM

      SeagoatLeo wrote:

      What was a horrible Lucia did include superb vocal performances and orchestral music accompanying the on stage depravity, the reverse of the Akhnaten production.

    • 2026-03-26 09:31:44 PM

      Mark Ward wrote:

      I appreciate the passionate dissent (which is exactly what new work should engender) even though I might take issue with the manner in which you express it. Be that as it may, no one walked out the night I went, and indeed the house was full, as it was for all performances this time around. If it had really been the failure you described ten years ago I wonder why they brought it back again, at considerable expense: at the time it received glowing notices and I bitterly regretted not going. The current run was such a hot ticket, in fact, that they added an extra performance which was also a sell-out - no mean feat. Audience walking out, btw, isn't necessarily the best way to judge a work's artistic merit, or to shore up your argument - case in point, The Rite of Spring. You will get little disagreement from me about the questionable choices of many a modern opera production, more often made for shock value than out of thoughtful consideration of the work itself. However, as I hope I argued in the article, all the choices made here had foundation in text and history, and I felt were highly creative approaches to presenting a piece that re-imagined what opera can be in every sense: musically, dramatically, scenically, staging etc. Obviously, this will not be to everyone's taste, but clearly it was very much to mine and many others'. As always in much matters, "chac'un à son goût" - but with a reasoned argument made to back up that taste, judgment and enjoyment - or lack thereof.

      • 2026-04-02 05:49:48 AM

        SeagoatLeo wrote:

        I know music history and performances that evoked hysteria like the Rite, or were under rehearsed and dismally presented (drunk Glazanov?) such as Rachmaninoff Symphony No.1. The L.A. Opera performance was expert but even my two friends in the chorus stated the rolling ball "ballet" was incoherent="nonsense." To give it this much attention on Tracking Angle instead of just a mild review is the problem I have with it. As I previously stated, there are many virtually unknown and a few recent composed operas that deserve the treatment given to Akhnanten. I've seen dozens of modern operas, some I enjoy and some are generally not emotionally engaging or repetitious. The latter two types fortunately are performed very infrequently now.

        • 2026-04-02 07:21:43 PM

          Mark Ward wrote:

          I'm afraid we are going to have to agree to disagree. In a lifetime of going to the opera and theater this was one of the most memorable evenings I've had. For me the juggling made perfect sense - it created an entirely apt visual analog for the music and underlying currents in the drama. Definitely worth writing about here. As you can see from the comments above, others would agree. But speaking of wayward opera directors, I just read this article abut the Tristan currently at the Met, given a "happy" ending. Ye gods! If you haven't read it already, you might like giving it your attention. https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/2026/03/31/metropolitan-opera-tristan-isolde-ending/