Acoustic Sounds
Lyra

Gillian Welch and David Rawlings

Woodland

Music

Sound

Woodland Studio

Label: Acony

Produced By: David Rawlings

Engineered By: Ken Scott, Matt Andrews, David Rawlings

Mixed By: David Rawlings, Matt Andrews

Mastered By: Ted Jensen at Sterling Sound and David Rawlings at Woodland Studios

Lacquers Cut By: David Rawlings

By: Michael Fremer

December 30th, 2024

Format:

Vinyl

A Front Row Seat at the Corner of Forlorn and Regret With Gillian Welch and David Rawlings

in "you are there" spectacularly natural sound

Rarely does regret sound so affirming, loss so found, emptiness so filling, distance so near and dated so au courant as do those dark sentiments on this collection of woe filled songs that though relentlessly morose, somehow bring to the listener peace and resolve.

Though the Welch/Rawlings musical style remains fixed in mountain balladry and many of the themes are timeless, there's modernity too in "Hashtag"—an unrelentingly down road song about chasing the dream, "The Day the Mississippi Died", which needs no further elucidation other than along with the ecological angle is a plea for tolerance, and more than a few about break ups and growing old. Cheers!

The duo's vocalizing remains magical and mesmerizing. At one point during "The Day The Mississippi Died" Welch breaks into a falsetto that will shiver your timbers. There's nothing spare about the backing arrangements that include on some tracks drums, bass, pedal steel, fiddle and strings all subtly dialed into a tasteful blend that never overwhelms the acoustic guitar magic for which the couple is renowned. You're sure to exit your flrst play exalted and even refreshed despite the flowing dark undercurrents.

Of course the AAA sound is breathtakingly transparent three-dimensional and timbrally and texturally honest. You are in the Woodland Studios witnessing the performances. Image solidity is of the "reach out and touch" variety.

The Woodland Studios high resolution digital assets arrived months ago sent by a publicist. But I didn't want to spoil the experience so chose to wait for the record release. Word never came and I moved on to other things. My regret. Should have bought as soon as it was released but glad I waited to listen deeply into the Rawlings cut—his first on his restored lathe.

David Rawlings' restored Neumann lathe at Woodland Studios

The record, plated by Gary Salstrom and pressed at Paramount (the former VMP pressing plant now at least in part owned by Rawlings) on a semi transparent vinyl formulation that may or may not be a Neotech vinyl formulation, is perfectly flat and quiet as this music demands it to be, with a textured paper gatefold jacket that's equally up to the presentational task.

If you've already purchased this you know what I mean. If you haven't, I can't recommend a record more than this one. And how great and not surprising is it to see legendary recording engineer Ken Scott in the credits?

Music Specifications

Catalog No: ACNY-2416LP

Pressing Plant: Paramount

SPARS Code: AAA

Speed/RPM: 33 1/3

Weight: 140 grams

Size: 12"

Channels: Stereo

Source: original analog master tapes

Presentation: Single LP

Comments

  • 2024-12-31 04:27:22 AM

    Silk Dome Mid wrote:

    I bought this on the strength of their previous work, and Michael is right about the sound and artistry found on the disc. It's quite stunning. Unfortunately, the songs evoke such a profound feeling of sadness that I've only listened to it once. Not what I need right now. In the spring I'll give it another spin.

  • 2024-12-31 04:48:07 AM

    bwb wrote:

    I bought an advance copy and I hear something very different. I struggle to understand the words. I had to get the lyric sheet to follow along. Her vocals are down in the mix and overall I would say the sound is all a bit edgy. No where near an 11

    On the other hand, my copy of “The Harrow and the Harvest” is reference quality . Granted just the 2 of them, but vocals are outstanding , every word crystal clear , in the room as they say, as is everything else. Truly a show off your system disc. If this new one is 11 , H&H is a 15. “Soul Journey” also blows away this one.

    Maybe early pressings are different than yours. My assessment of it certainly is very different than yours.

    • 2025-01-03 04:32:05 PM

      Derek wrote:

      I too bought an early copy and agree fully with your assessment of it, ok but nothing close to an 11…maybe worth getting a more recent copy? My pressing quality is also only second rate, some surface noise and a slight warp. Hmmm

      • 2025-01-05 08:48:25 PM

        bwb wrote:

        I sent them a message asking about the possibility of advanced pressings being different than the more recent. I have yet to hear back but it has only been a few days. As technically savvy as Rawlings is and their track record of excellent recordings, I suspect he would be concerned about it. I listened to several more of their records this weekend as I have them all, and my copy of Woodlands is by far the worst of the bunch.

        • 2025-01-05 09:03:29 PM

          bwb wrote:

          shame we can't edit our comments. My order was fulfilled on October 21. Curious if those who rave about it have a different pressing, or those who do not have what I have. Stamped in the runout is

          ACNY-2416-A-5 DR WSS BB ACNY-2416-B-2 DR WSS BB

          • 2025-01-05 09:06:55 PM

            bwb wrote:

            Mr. Fremer, it is now 2025. Do you think you could bring this comment section into at least the 2000's to allow markup, editing and links, or god forbid, an image? And a window that gives us more than 3 lines of text so we can at least read what we wrote without scrolling?

            • 2025-01-07 06:07:36 AM

              David L wrote:

              See this story

              • 2025-01-07 04:56:47 PM

                bwb wrote:

                Yes, I've seen that story and chart, but again, it is 2025. It should not be necessary to have a cheat sheet and add code to your text to get it to work. And without a preview function if you mistype the code you can't go back and edit it..... No matter how you spin it, this is the most awkward , antiquated forum on the web. Thanks for the feedback though.

                • 2025-01-07 06:30:18 PM

                  David L wrote:

                  Markdown isn't antiquated, its the state of the art in some circles.

                  • 2025-01-07 07:43:41 PM

                    bwb wrote:

                    anyone who argues that this forum is state of the art simply wants to argue .... I would insert a sarcastic smiley face but of course this antiquated forum won't allow that.

            • 2025-01-07 06:11:29 AM

              David L wrote:

              Also see this chart

  • 2024-12-31 12:24:22 PM

    Erik Charpentier wrote:

    "au courant" not "au currant". Merci de ne pas massacrer la langue française!!

    • 2024-12-31 07:08:29 PM

      Michael Fremer wrote:

      fickst....thanks

  • 2024-12-31 02:00:40 PM

    PeterG wrote:

    Whoa! How can I not buy this? Plus, even that YouTube is haunting. Now on order...thanks!

  • 2024-12-31 02:47:50 PM

    JackG wrote:

    Very much agree after a few plays. Gorgeous record on all counts. The perfection of the way their voices meld is second only to John and Paul in my book. Looking forward to seeing them at Carnegie Hall in 2025.

  • 2024-12-31 08:52:40 PM

    Lemon Curry wrote:

    I've read that Rawlings is a tech nerd, but the fact that he actually cut the lacquer himself AND nailed it, is remarkable.

    • 2025-01-01 05:48:09 PM

      Eugene Harrington wrote:

      I had this on pre-order here in Ireland, and I was very happy indeed when I finally placed it on my turntable and played it. The pressing quality is astoundingly good, without a tick or a pop across both sides. The disc is flat, glossy and centred. It is very pleasing to me personally to see a new American plant achieve such monumental excellence in the technical, manufacturing sphere. Increasingly, I have found that the quality of vinyl records emanating from U.S. plants these days is encouragingly excellent. No more pre-purchase anxiety that you might receive something less than you expected, therefore. That, for me, is a marvellous step forward. The music? It is stellar, and the instrumentation is breathtakingly vivid and real, conveying, as Michael states, a "You are there" aural experience. Quite honestly, this is the album of the year for me! It is wonderful to have artists like Gillian and David who actually care so much about the quality of their work. Paramount Pressing hit it out of the park with this release. My previous experiences with 'The Harrow and the Harvest' and "Soul Journey", both pressed at QRP, were disappointing in terms of a technical manufacturing standpoint. I had issues with both pressings. Not so with this one. And the songs? Yes, they evoke a certain amount of sadness and melancholy. Music is all about emotions however, happy and sad as the case may be. Just sit back and enjoy this piece of analogue joy in 2024/25.

    • 2025-01-01 06:07:50 PM

      PeterPani wrote:

      I bought the 15 ips reel-to-reel of "The Harrow & The Harvest". Rawlings made all tape copies on machines by himself. The tapes came in a wonderful package. In fact nicer than from Tapeprojet or Ultratape. And the sound from the tapes is analog heaven.

  • 2025-01-02 01:47:25 AM

    Jeff wrote:

    I agree with Michael’s 11/11 grading, this is a stunning performance and recording. I can’t get enough of it. To me the melancholy is just life, portrayed in beautiful melodies. (To deep for this thread, I know)

    • 2025-01-02 04:42:50 PM

      Jeffrey Puckett wrote:

      You’re so incredibly deep that I am, frankly, stunned.

    • 2025-01-02 11:39:58 PM

      Chris O'Shea wrote:

      I'm Irish...we LOVE sad, melancholy music....it's in our DNA why fight it?

  • 2025-01-04 01:14:35 AM

    Jim Shue wrote:

    More like a 4/9

    This is Trustafarian Turgid Dirge Music

  • 2025-01-04 06:51:57 PM

    Alan wrote:

    I purchased a copy in late December. A bad pressing. Cut 3 on side A has significant distortion. Returned.

    • 2025-01-05 02:52:23 PM

      Derek wrote:

      So with my comment above in reply to the bwb posting, it does seem as if the quality of this LP is variable, a shame because the music is great